North Carolina health insurers must put patient care ahead of profits.

View the Panel Discussion and Get the New White Paper

What Will It Take to Fix North Carolina's Health Care?

About Us

Meet the North Carolina Center for Health & Democracy

The North Carolina Center for Health and Democracy studies how health care is working in the state, helping patients, communities, and policymakers understand the influence insurance companies have on costs, access, outcomes, and the long-term sustainability of care for North Carolinians. The Center shares publicly available data, information, and original analysis.

Care Over Greed: Everyone should be able to get affordable health care. Yet insurance companies are denying care in the name of profits.

Stand Up to Misinformation: Shine a light on how insurers harm Americans by overcharging them and dictating where patients can receive care.

North Carolinians deserve better from their health insurance companies. The time is now for North Carolina's insurers to put patient care over profits — so quality health care remains accessible across the state.

North Carolina Health Care by the Numbers:

  • Health insurance denial numbers have left patients with big medical bills and less access to care. An estimated 18% of national in-network claims were denied by health insurance companies in 2020, or about 42.3 million in-network claims, according to data on ACA coverage analyzed by the Kaiser Family Foundation.
  • In North Carolina alone, KFF found that 2,901,677 in-network claims were denied in 2020. Furthermore, KFF estimates that only .1% of denied claims are ever appealed and according to national insurance and claims numbers, more than 32% of denied claims were overturned once appealed.
  • North Carolina was ranked 39th in the nation by WalletHub in their annual “States with the Best Health Care” survey.
    • The state was also ranked 38th in average monthly insurance premium price,
    • Two of three “bottom-ranked indicators” were employee insurance costs and high out-of-pocket medical spending.
  • North Carolina ranks third in the nation for rural hospital closures.

New Study: Only 8.3% of North Carolinians Believe Health Insurers Have Their Best Interests in Mind

At the request of the North Carolina Center for Health and Democracy, Meredith Poll recently carried out original research on how North Carolina consumers view health insurance. It found that North Carolinians hold health insurance companies more responsible than any other part of the health care system for rising costs. Although most North Carolinians are satisfied with their current insurer, only 8.3 percent believe their health insurer has their best interests in mind.

The Center for Health and Democracy (CHD) is a non-profit led by Wendell Potter that works to transform America's system of health coverage. Its core belief is that health care should be guided not by industry profits but by the needs and rights of every American to receive quality care without worrying about cost. Learn more about the Center for Health & Democracy.

Profits and Premium Costs

Coming out of the COVID pandemic, health insurance companies are seeing record revenue and profits. National insurers such as UnitedHealth Group and CVS/Aetna reported more than $30 billion and $10 billion, respectively, in 2021.

North Carolina insurers are no exception. The state's largest insurer, Blue Cross Blue Shield of North Carolina, reported $10.7 billion in annual revenue in 2021 and nearly $570 million in net revenue. WRAL in North Carolina reported that "the top eight executives made an extra $9 million between them."

Keep in mind that insurance companies largely profit from unused premiums. With roughly a 60 percent market share in North Carolina, BCBSNC largely controls health insurance premium prices, rate adjustments, and contract negotiations with health care providers. According to the North Carolina Department of Insurance, BCBSNC has more than $9 billion in written premiums.

An August 2022 survey by financial services company Aon reports that U.S. employers will pay 6.5% more on average for employee health coverage in 2023. According to the North Carolina Department of Insurance, BCBSNC sought to raise 2022 individual premiums by nearly 10% and small group premiums by 6%.

Even if health insurers recognize that health care is too expensive, they have not stopped collecting revenue, earning profits, and pushing rate hikes.

First of all, we understand that health care is too expensive
— Mitch Perry
Chief Financial Officer, BCBSNC in WRAL interview

Claim Denials and Appeals

Since the pandemic, health insurance claim denials have left patients facing large medical bills and reduced access to care. This summer, the Kaiser Family Foundation released data on national and state denial rates for 2020, during the pandemic.

An estimated 18% of in-network claims were denied in 2020. To put that in perspective, roughly 42.3 million patients who visited in-network health care facilities had coverage denied. In North Carolina, those denials numbered in the millions: 2,901,677 claims were denied in 2020.

Perhaps most surprising is that most denied claims are never appealed, even though appeals are often successful. KFF data estimates that only .1% of denied claims are ever appealed, and according to national insurance and claims figures, more than 32% of denied claims were overturned once appealed.

Confusion for Consumers

Health care is often confusing and complicated. Yet while other parts of the health care industry are frequently criticized for unclear data, insurers get a free pass.

Consider a new Forbes Advisor survey that found Americans are confused about their health insurance.

The Forbes survey of 2,000 insured Americans found that more than three-quarters could not identify "coinsurance," and half incorrectly defined copayment and deductible. The survey "also found fairly significant knowledge gaps about open enrollment, Health Savings Accounts and medical billing."

Combined with the KFF data above, it becomes clear that Americans' difficulty navigating their health insurance leads to denied claims and higher costs for patients. As the nation's largest health plans keep posting record profits, this issue matters greatly to North Carolinians.

An older North Carolina couple moved from the state insurance exchange plan to Medicare after the husband turned 65.

"When Blue Cross switched Melissa to her new exchange plan, Jim says, the insurer determined that the amount she had paid toward her deductible would not roll over to her new plan. The couple had already paid her 2019 individual deductible of $6,750. Faced with the need to start over again, she would have to pay another $6,750 before her insurance coverage kicked in later this year."

The mandate that requires insurers to post the amounts they pay to healthcare clinicians for the services they provide to patients, the second part of a federal transparency ruling issued in October 2020, is live.

Insurers were given a 12-month lead and an extension to have price transparency numbers ready by July 2022.

The data that has been shared from insurers has been called everything from a “data dump” to being “inaccessible to mere mortals,” with load times of up to five minutes on one insurer’s website and more than 45,000 entries.

According to the New York Times, "The nation's Blue Cross plans have reached a tentative $2.7 billion settlement in a federal lawsuit filed by their customers that accuses the group of engaging in a conspiracy to thwart competition among the individual companies…"

"One in three Americans is covered by a Blue Cross plan, and these plans are often the largest health insurer in their respective state or region."

Subscribe for updates on how Blue Cross is failing to prioritize the care of North Carolinians.

Name

The Center's work centers on a simple idea: health coverage should serve patients, not industry profits. By tracking insurer profits and premiums, claim denials and appeals, consumer confusion, and legal or regulatory disputes, the Center gives North Carolinians the information they need to push for a health care system that puts care first.